This excellent “Letter to the Editor”
appeared in the Mesabi Daily News,
the largest circulation daily newspaper
on Minnesota's Iron Range.
Posted: Saturday, March 2, 2013 10:37 pm
Metsa talks unions, but behaves otherwise
State Representative Jason Metsa (DFL) and I have something in common.
We are both former union organizers and understand the difference
between the historical union (which stood up against corporate abuses)
and today’s union (which enables corporate abuses).
Rep. Metsa
is now working on a bill that would add labor union history to our
public school curriculum. In my opinion, this is a decent idea if we
also educate students (and adults) about the current reality of labor
unions and how non-heroic much of their activities are today.
For example, Rep. Metsa’s idea of “pro-union” is to support
copper-nickel (sulfide mining) and companies such as PolyMet, whose
parent company Glencore is responsible for busting unions in Columbia
and Peru, while polluting the water, then leaving locals to clean up the
mess. To be an apologist for PolyMet /Glencore while considering
yourself a hero of the working class, is absurd.
Today’s labor
unions also squander millions on politicians like Barack Obama who
stacks his cabinet with Goldman Sachs executives, advocates job-killing
free trade bills (TPP), and squashes union organizing rights (FAA
Re-Authorization Act).
To quote the author Chris Hedges, modern unions are “in collaboration with the power elite.”
Rep. Metsa should not idealize the historical union while ignoring how
his own union behavior is the exact opposite. Metsa is a company man, a
lapdog for the mining companies, the Chamber of Commerce, and the
union-busters of America.
Union history should be a model for today’s unions. It has not been.
Nathan Ness
St. Paul
Link: http://www.virginiamn.com/opinion/letters/article_083f6340-83bc-11e2-8ee6-001a4bcf887a.html